A lawyer uses Chatgpt to write a judicial document, he received a sanction for justice

Chatgpt

Chatgpt is the Openai chatbot, based on the GPT artificial intelligence model, making it possible to answer all kinds of questions or requests. Available in free online version.

• License:
  Free license
• Author :
  OPENAI
• Operating systems:
  Windows 10/11, Apple Silicon macOS, online service, Android, iOS iPhone / iPad
• Category :
  IA

AI, however, has the reputation to distribute false information. The fraud was discovered when the judicial authorities noted that the document, which was written by a legal assistant from the cabinet, contained quotes and other invented elements. The lawyer recognized the facts and apologized for this heavy professional fault according to the Huffington Post.

A lawyer sentenced for the use of chatgpt

The document in question is a request on appeal with elements generated by AI according to the defense lawyer. For example, a benchmark for a criminal case hallucinated by Chatgpt which does not exist in any legal data. Other quotes are invented with references that have nothing to do with the case.

The main lawyer says that his legal assistant has not warned him of the use of Chatgpt until the discovery of these invented elements. The facts were immediately recognized and it was proposed to reimburse the lawyers incurred in this case.

During the hearing, the lawyer reiterated his confessions and assured that he did not participate in the drafting and the request of this document, but also that he did not check the accuracy before signing it. The consequences: the legal assistant was dismissed and a strict policy around the use was implemented, this was not the case at the time of the facts.

“In this case, the applicant’s lawyers failed in their verification obligations as members of the Utah State bar by subjecting a request citing a fictitious precedent generated by Chatgpt.”concluded the court of appeal in its decision.

The lawyer must pay the defense costs for the request and the hearing, reimburse his customer the costs incurred to prepare the file and attend the hearing. $ 1,000 will be paid to the association and justice for all which offers free legal services to fragile citizens of UTAH.

Want to save even more? Discover Our promo codes Selected for you.